TROY - Robert Brewer testified Wednesday in Troy about being assaulted earlier this month in Wells Township, but he didn't have to say a word.
The very visible injury on his left eye area was perhaps the strongest evidence of the attack.
According to police, Brewer, 52, of Elmira, N.Y., was punched by Leonard E. Storms, 45, of Elmira, N.Y. between 4:40 p.m. and 4:50 p.m. July 5 on School Street in Wells Township.
Police said Brewer's serious injury to his left eye and facial area will more than likely result in permanent loss of vision. Hospital officials told police that Brewer sustained a ruptured left eye and multiple facial fractures around the left eye and nose area.
Brewer testified that Storms had been "in a rage" when he punched him.
Following a preliminary hearing, Magisterial District Judge Jonathan Wilcox bound all charges against Storms over to the Bradford County Court of Common Pleas.
Wilcox declined to reduce Storms' $80,000 bail, due to Storms' criminal history that Wilcox described as "extremely extensive" and "very extensive." When asked for comment, Wilcox said that Storms' criminal history consisted of "a lot" of criminal mischief incidents. Prosecuting attorney Al Ondrey from the Bradford County District Attorney's office described it as a "significant" criminal history.
In addition, Storms agreed to waive his formal arraignment July 31 and enter a "not guilty" plea at that time.
Storms is charged with two aggravated assault charges, one a felony of the first degree and one a felony of the second degree, and the following other charges: simple assault, criminal trespass, harassment, disorderly conduct, and criminal mischief. Wilcox declined a request from the defense to dismiss all but one of those charges, the aggravated assault charge for punching Brewer.
In an affidavit, Pennsylvania State Police Cpl. Joshua Thompson said he and Trooper Robert Richter were assigned July 5 to investigate an assault that had occurred at a woman's residence on School Street in Wells Township.
The 43-year-old woman, with a Millerton address, was called as a witness Wednesday, and testified that Storms came to her residence unannounced and assaulted Brewer, who was inside the house. After the hearing, she objected to police describing her as Storms' ex-girlfriend. She said they had only dated briefly, and she was not his "girlfriend."
She testified how she told Storms to leave, when he arrived at her house, and how Storms "just kind of went on by" and went over to where Brewer was sitting in the house, yelling at him and punching him.
"It was quick and fast and over and done with," she told the court.
A photograph of Brewer's injuries was shown in court.
"It got a lot worse," the woman said of the injuries, after looking at the photograph.
She testified that Storms told Brewer to "clean his face off," after punching him, and how Storms told Brewer not to come back to her house. She testified that Storms doesn't like Brewer, but said she didn't know why.
The woman said that Storms "smelled like booze," prior to assaulting Brewer.
"When someone is in your face screaming at you, you can tell," she testified in response to questioning from Carrie Donald, from the county public defender office, who was the defense attorney for Storms.
Taking the stand, Brewer testified about the loss of vision in his left eye and the many hours of surgery he has had to endure, and said he is still in pain. Brewer talked about the impact of Storms' punch on his eye and face in terms of an explosion.
In 2011, Brewer testified, he had some surgery on his eye, due to a previous mishap. There had been a chance that vision in his eye would improve, had it not been for Storms' punch, he testified.
He also testified about the damage to his Harley-Davidson motorcycle, which police said Storms picked up and threw. Prior to Storms' throwing the motorcycle, Brewer said, it had been in "mint condition."
"There was not one scratch at all on that motorcycle, not one scratch at all."
Brewer testified that the damage to the motorcycle was cosmetic rather than mechanical.
Cpl. Thompson, who also took the stand, testified about Brewer's left eye being severely swollen and black and blue in color while he was interviewed, and then being "completely shut" by the end of the interview.
According to the police criminal complaint, Storms tried to injure Brewer by striking him with his truck while Brewer was trying to leave on his motorcycle. At that time, police said, Brewer didn't sustain further injury, but his motorcycle was further damaged.
Brewer testified that Storms backed up and hit the front wheel of his motorcycle. There was testimony that Storms commented that he was sorry and didn't know his truck was in reverse. After the hearing, the woman said the comment sounded sarcastic.
After the incident, Brewer had gone to a store to call for help, and he testified that Storms took his phone from him and threw it, inadvertently hitting a vehicle passing by on the road.
Brewer also testified that Storms was obsessed with the woman and wanted her to "obey" him.
Storms, who sometimes looked straight ahead at Brewer as he testified on the stand, did not testify during the preliminary hearing.
Eric Hrin can be reached at (570) 297-5251; email: reviewtroy@thedailyreview.com.